Thursday 12 May 2011

The Young and the Old

Dear Readers,

Today, I will be talking about the difference in how the young and the old solve a particular situation.

Previously, there have been many STOMP articles regarding students misbehaving in public places. In return, these witnesses post them up onto STOMP, supposedly to shame the school from which the students are from. Many classmates have already commented on these incidents like the ice-cream incident which happened in our school. It may be the hard and cold truth, but it is undeniable that posting articles on the Internet without considering the consequences is the way of the Internet-savvy younger generation. What about the older generation then?

Today, when I was returning back from school with my classmate on the bus, we saw four students from an elite school fooling around. There was a student sitting on the floor, whilst the other three were shouting at the top of their voices and laughing continuously. The noise suddenly grew unbearable and to be heard, we had to talk rather loudly (which was quite hard since both of us were having a sore throat). Of course, we know this is wrong as it would reflect extremely badly on our school, since we are wearing the school uniform.

My friend said that he wanted to take a photograph of the students and post it on STOMP. I guess he must have been joking, because he did not do as he had said. When the bus reached our stop, an uncle clad in a chequered shirt and listening to an MP3 walked towards them.

“When you are wearing the school uniform, you represent your school. If you don’t respect your own school, how do you expect us to?” he asked in quite an annoyed manner. The students looked down at the ground, feeling rather remorseful and abashed. I sympathised with the students, because I know how it feels to be scolded in front of a large crowd. The fact that the person who scolded them was a stranger did not help alleviate the situation, but instead worsens it a lot.

I agree that the uncle had done the right thing, but maybe it was not the best way to solve it. He could have said it in a nicer and friendlier tone, so that it went across more as just a lesson than a lecture or a scolding.

Now, comparing the younger generation and the older generation in the way which they settle issues, we see a distinct difference. The former adopts a more “humiliating” approach to point out the party’s mistake but does not teach him/her what is the right thing to do. On the other hand, the older generation tends to be able to teach him/her by minimising the humiliation or embarrassment the person feels.

Therefore, my ten-cents worth is that we, the younger generation, must definitely learn from the older generation in considering the consequences before doing something online, be it posting on a social media platform (as many, if not all, of us – the young and reckless ones – have done). Instead, we should think of what is the best way to do something, in this case, teach the person what the right thing to do is.

Best Regards,
Nathan :)

5 comments:

  1. Hi All!

    Oh no! My point has been rebutted by a newspaper article in today's copy of "The Straits Times", which reads that Mr Wang, 63, posted on Facebook and many other social media platforms that a young man, 23, refused to give up the priority seat.

    Well, I guess, in any situation, there will always be exceptions and in-betweens. :)

    Best Regards,
    Nathan :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Dear Nathan,

    I agree. I was just joking when I said I wanted to take a photograph and post it on STOMP, since my camera is quite huge and it would cause suspicion. I was also stopped when I considered how I disliked people doing so, thus I did not do so.

    I really admired the uncle. He practiced moral courage and taught me a valuable lesson. Instead of hiding behind an iPhone or a camera, we should go up and tell the people where they have gone wrong.

    Regards,
    2I125

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Kee Xuan,

    Yes, I understood that you were joking. However, out of curiosity, may I ask: if you had a small camera which would not arouse any suspicion, would you have taken the photograph and posted it on STOMP?

    Best Regards,
    Nathan :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dear Nathan,

    I think you have made a valid observation of today’s society, but there are also many exceptions to the norm.

    First of all, I disagree with you that publicly shaming a misbehaving member of public will only serve to humiliate him. I think that this is very much dependent on the mindset and attitudes of the individual at wrong. For instance, in the example you raised, the fact that the students felt remorseful and abashed meant that they had a sense of shame and understood that they were in the wrong. However, if someone is an attention seeker and just wants to get the attention, or they do not really care about how others perceive them, then regardless of whether a not a direct shaming campaign is launched against them will not serve much to correct their behaviour. Instead, a public shaming campaign could bring awareness to the public on the ugliness of his behaviour and more people can correct and admonish the behaviour if they see future inconsiderate people in public places.

    With regards to STOMP, there are various people who visit and utilise the site. There are those who gain entertainment and joy be criticising others or looking at how others are being criticised. In my opinion, these kind of people are the most pathetic of all. There are also those who might feel strongly against the inconsiderate behaviour of some members of the public and turn to STOMP as a solution by posting those ugly photos online. Instead of turning to STOMP, they could instead write in to a forum like the ST Forum where it might be more effective.

    Of course, I still discourage the usage of STOMP as it only shows how uncivilised and disgusting our society really is.

    Regards,
    Ivan

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dear Ivan,

    Ok... thanks?

    Regards,
    Nathan (:

    ReplyDelete